Apprenticeships and technical routes are being championed as a path to stronger growth and higher pay for many young people, with industry groups urging a cultural shift so vocational excellence is prized alongside academic study. According to Logistics UK, better alignment between training and labour market needs could unlock talent and help fill persistent skills gaps across the economy. Industry analysis from Barclays and other commentators has already shown that in some fields apprentices can out-earn graduates over their careers, strengthening the case for greater investment in work-based learning.

Untapped youth talent and skills shortages

Bethany Windsor, head of skills policy at Logistics UK, told National Apprenticeship Week audiences that the country is failing to match a large pool of young people with available work, citing almost one million 16-to-24-year-olds not in education, employment or training alongside some 213,000 vacancies attributed to skills shortages. She argued this gap reflects an education system that has historically prioritised academic achievement over technical pathways and called for parity of esteem between the two. Industry campaigners and think-tanks have made similar points about the mismatch between qualifications and labour-market demand.

Higher apprenticeships and earnings progression

Logistics UK highlights both immediate and longer-term earnings gains from higher-level apprenticeships, noting that five years after qualifying, higher apprentices earn on average around £37,300 compared with about £32,100 for the average university graduate. Wider research, including analysis from Sutton Trust, supports the notion that at advanced levels lifetime earnings can exceed those of many graduates, with top apprentices often out-earning graduates from lower-tier universities and in some sectors earning substantially more across a career.

"The apprenticeship sector has spent many years gaining the kudos to rival traditional higher level academic routes, and now provides an important pipeline of talent, built to address each sectors and companies individual needs, whilst providing skills to carry out the role in Realtime as opposed to a just a desk-based knowledge of ‘how to’. This shift has been welcomed by employers and with UCAS now assigning points to apprenticeships, the parity is welcomed. This isn’t degrees versus apprenticeships. It’s about building a genuinely dual system where technical and academic excellence carry equal weight, status and expectation".

Mark Bremner, Director at MBKB.

Debt, fees and lifetime returns

The economics of apprenticeships can be stark when tuition fees and student debt are taken into account. Reports drawing on data from Barclays and the Centre for Economics and Business Research show that in certain sectors such as arts, media and publishing apprentices have, in some cases, earned nearly three times as much as comparable graduates over their working lives, reinforcing calls to broaden viable routes into good jobs beyond the university path.

Reforming the levy to boost flexibility

Logistics UK is backing proposed changes to the Apprenticeship Levy, welcoming government plans to replace it with a Growth and Skills Levy that would allow employers more flexibility to spend funds on non-apprenticeship, sector-relevant training. The organisation argues Skills England should move quickly to approve a wider set of courses for levy support and to sustain careers-awareness campaigns such as Generation Logistics to attract new entrants into essential roles. Similar proposals have been advocated by policy groups urging a rebalancing of public funding towards technical education to tackle skills shortages.

"The growth skills levy should bring more flexibility, though there is some concern too, Gov.UK recently defunded Levels 7s for most apprentices and are currently reviewing funding of higher level programmes, most notably leadership and management, we would strongly urge the government to take alternative options to address budget restraints as defunding any more apprenticeships will be counterproductive and remove a core talent pipeline for current and future business growth. Flexibility is welcome, but dilution would be a mistake. Any new Growth and Skills Levy must protect quality, progression and employer co-investment in real capability, not short courses across limited sectors”. 

Mark Bremner, Director at MBKB.

A two-track model for economic success

As a sector specialist and approved apprenticeship provider, Logistics UK points to its own programmes, spanning Level 2 Traffic Coordinator apprenticeships to Level 5 Operations Manager pathways, as examples of employer-informed training designed to build practical capability and strategic leadership within the logistics workforce. While universities remain central to the UK’s economic success, business groups and research bodies argue that a two-track approach, combining world-class universities with strengthened technical training and clearer progression routes, will be essential to address labour shortages and improve social mobility.

Total reward is not just about salary, its about equipping your employees to be the best versions of themselves. Click here to visit the Knowledge Hub to discover more insights into bringing the best out of your employees.